Caption
Will the viewer still know what the image represents if the original caption disappears?
Guide / Synthetic media
Generated and edited visuals can help tell stories. Problems begin when a viewer is asked to treat appearance as proof.
An artist can build a city that never existed. A teacher can use a sample interface to explain a process. Neither image asks a viewer to trust a real person's credentials. Trouble begins when an edited image is separated from its context and offered as proof of something it cannot establish.
Look at what accompanies the image: the caption, the account that shared it, and the decision being requested. In The Face in the Rain, every visible second of a clip is real within the story. The cut is what misleads the crowd.
Questions to carry forward
Will the viewer still know what the image represents if the original caption disappears?
Does it appear to speak for a person or institution that never approved it?
Can someone trace the claim back to a person or record willing to stand behind it?
Could someone lose money, access, safety, or a good name if they believed the wrong account?